A spacious lawn beneath mature autumn trees beside a well-kept white brick home in an established leafy neighborhood.

How to Read a Blossomwood Asking Price

A 1960 house sits at the end of a cul-de-sac on Wilma Circle SE, in the Blossomwood subdivision. It has 3,364 square feet and a walkout basement on a 0.67-acre lot, and the asking price is $249,900. The listing doesn't oversell it. It says the house could be saved, and that at this price a buyer could also tear it down and build on what it calls a large, flat build site. The utilities are off.

That listing is the most useful number in Blossomwood right now. It isn't really a house price. It's close to a land price, and once you know roughly what the land asks for, the rest of the neighborhood's listings start to make sense.

A Blossomwood lot asks about a quarter-million dollars on its own

Blossomwood was land before it was a neighborhood. James W. Fraser's nursery acreage south of Maple Hill Cemetery later became the Monterrey, Monte Vista and Blossomwood subdivisions, and the nursery had closed by 1929, according to the Huntsville Historical Review. The houses came after World War II, and the active listings show it. Most of the single-family homes for sale in the neighborhood in mid-November 2026 were built between 1960 and 1966, on lots from about four-tenths of an acre to eight-tenths.

The listings say plainly what they think is being sold. The Wilma Circle listing describes itself as a lot. A 1961 house at 825 Watts Drive SE in Fagan Springs Estates, asking $349,900 on a 0.45-acre corner lot, asks buyers to bring a contractor and decide between renovating the house and building new. At 518 Cleermont Drive, also in Fagan Springs Estates, the asking price is $499,000 for about 2,590 square feet on 0.8 acre that backs up to Land Trust property. That listing closes by telling buyers to pay for the setting and remake the house to suit themselves.

If a 0.67-acre lot with a house that needs to be saved or removed asks $249,900, then the land under a typical Blossomwood listing is worth something like a quarter-million dollars to the market. That's one listing and one cul-de-sac, and lots here differ in slope, size and what backs up to them. Still, it gives a starting point, and it changes how every other price in the neighborhood reads.

Subtract the lot, and the houses sort themselves

Here are the Blossomwood-area single-family listings from the 1960s Fagan Springs Estates and Mountainbrook stock that were active at this writing, with the $249,900 lot benchmark taken off each one. All figures are asking prices, not closed sales.

Address Subdivision Built Sq. ft. Lot Asking Left after $249,900 Per sq. ft. of house
825 Watts Dr SE Fagan Springs Estates 1961 1,630 0.45 ac $349,900 $100,000 about $61
1400 Darnell St SE Mountain Brook 1963 3,319 0.44 ac $425,000 $175,100 about $53
416 Owens Dr SE Fagan Springs Estates 1964 3,440 0.55 ac $474,900 $225,000 about $65
518 Cleermont Dr Fagan Springs Estates not listed 2,590 0.8 ac $499,000 $249,100 about $96
1600 Mountainbrook Dr SE Mountainbrook 1964 2,077 0.41 ac $570,000 $320,100 about $154
2204 Toll Gate Rd SE Fagan Springs Estates 1963 3,117 0.48 ac $684,900 $435,000 about $140

Take the lot out, and the houses split into two groups by condition, not by size or age. Watts, Darnell and Owens all come out between roughly $53 and $65 per square foot of house. Watts and Darnell are listed as needing work. Darnell is offered as-is and priced for the updates it still needs, even after a new roof, HVAC and water heater in 2025. Owens is described as remodeled, and its lot is larger than most, but it still lands with the first group. Mountainbrook Drive and Toll Gate Road come out between about $140 and $154. The Mountainbrook house is marketed as a high-end renovation with custom cabinetry and a new roof in 2025. The Toll Gate house has a new quartz kitchen, a remodeled primary bath and a walk-out basement suite with its own entrance.

The gap between those two groups is about $80 to $90 per square foot of house. In practice, that is the price the asking market is putting on a finished renovation in Blossomwood this fall. A buyer looking at a work-needed house can compare that number with a contractor's bid. If the bid comes in well under the gap, buying the as-is house and renovating it is the better deal on paper. If it comes in over, the remodeled house is the cheaper way to end up in a finished home on the same kind of lot.

Cleermont falls between the two groups for a clear reason. It sits on 0.8 acre against Land Trust land, so its land is likely worth more than the Wilma Circle benchmark, and part of what looks like house value is really land value.

Why price per square foot points the wrong way here

Price per square foot is the first number a buyer comparing neighborhoods uses, and in Blossomwood it misleads. Divide the full asking price by the square footage, and 825 Watts, a 1,630-square-foot house its own listing says to rethink from scratch, comes out at about $215. That's nearly the same as the remodeled 2204 Toll Gate at about $220. Darnell, at about $128, looks like the bargain of the group. Owens, at about $138, looks close to it.

Both readings are distortions caused by the land. When a lot worth roughly a quarter-million dollars is in every price, a small house carries a big share of land cost per square foot, and a large house spreads the same land cost across more space. Watts isn't overpriced, and Darnell isn't cheap. They're the same lot-heavy product at two house sizes. The downtown median price post on this blog made a similar point about blended numbers. In Blossomwood the blending happens inside a single listing, where land and building share one price tag.

This also explains why the highest asking prices here aren't always on the newest houses. A custom 2001 house at 904 Corinth Circle in Mountain View, with mountain views and more than 520 square feet of walkout porches, asks $694,000. That's only slightly more than the remodeled 1963 house on Toll Gate Road. Location on the slope and the finish of the house both count, but neither one moves the price as much as having the lot in the first place.

How the county's fall pace bears on these numbers

None of the figures above are closed sales, so the next question is how far asking prices move by closing. Countywide figures show how far that gap ran this fall. The Huntsville Area Association of Realtors reported that Madison County single-family homes received 98.6% of list price in September 2026 and spent a median of 41 days on market, with a median sale price of $334,000, up 3.5% from a year earlier. For the third quarter of 2026, HAAR's quarterly report put the county median at $341,036 with 42 average days on market. In that quarter, 20% of homes sold above list, 43% at list and 37% below.

Countywide, then, list and sale prices stayed within a couple of points of each other on average this fall, and more than a third of sales closed under list. Every listing in the table above asks more than the county median, so even the as-is houses sit above what a typical Madison County buyer pays. If a Blossomwood house closes under list, the house half of the price is the likeliest part to give, because the lot under it is close to the $249,900 benchmark already. Negotiation on these homes is mostly about what the house is worth. The land price is not really up for negotiation.

Questions buyers ask about Blossomwood pricing

Is the $249,900 Wilma Circle listing a reliable land value for all of Blossomwood? It's one asking price for one 0.67-acre cul-de-sac lot with a flat build site, so treat it as a benchmark and not an appraisal. Lots that are steeper, smaller or larger, like the 0.8-acre Cleermont lot backing up to the Land Trust, will ask more or less.

Are these asking prices current when you read this? They're asking prices as of mid-November 2026. Listings in this price range can go under contract, change price or come off the market within weeks, so check the Blossomwood neighborhood page for what's active now.

Does the same math work for a seller? It works in reverse. A Blossomwood seller's price starts at what the land alone asks, and the house's condition decides how far above that floor the listing can go. A home valuation built from current listings and closed sales nearby is the right place to start.

If you're weighing a Blossomwood house that needs work against a finished one a few streets away, Donna Burns can price the lot, the house and the renovation gap between them on the specific homes you're considering. Request a Confidential Consultation, and we'll go through the listings together before you write an offer.

Work With Donna

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram